Voting Home / Specialty Food and Drink / BEST Ice Cream Shop
| Nominee | Address | Rank |
|---|---|---|
| Alexander's Ice Cream | Multiple Locations | #10 |
| Chocolate Gallery | 5945 Crawfordsville Rd Speedway, IN | #14 |
| Cold Stone Creamery | 8395 E 116th St Fishers, IN | #2 |
| Frosty Boy | 40 W Main St New Palestine, IN | #6 |
| Gelato Da Vinci Bistro | Multiple Locations | #7 |
| Handel's Homemade Ice Cream & Yogurt | Multiple Locations | #1 |
| Jimmie's Dairy Bar | 7065 S State Road 67 Pendleton, IN | #11 |
| Mrs. Curl | 259 S Meridian St Greenwood, IN | #5 |
| Oberweis Ice Cream & Dairy Store | 14641 US 31 North, Suite 17 Carmel, IN | #8 |
| Ritter's Frozen Custard | Multiple Locations | #3 |
| The Sweet Treat Boutique | 8150 N Oaklandon Rd Indianapolis, IN | #13 |
| Traders Point Creamery | 9101 Moore Road Zionsville, IN | #4 |
| Twin Kiss | 700 S White Ave Sheridan, IN | #12 |
| YogoKiss | 4825 E 96th St, Ste 300 Indianapolis, IN | #9 |
2011 Winners + −
BEST Bakery BEST Chocolate BEST Coffee Shop BEST Cupcakes BEST Farmers' Market BEST Gourmet Grocery BEST Ice Cream Shop BEST Wine Shop2010 Winners + −
BEST Bakery BEST Chocolate BEST Coffee Shop BEST Cupcakes BEST Farmers' Market BEST Gourmet Grocery BEST Ice Cream Shop BEST Wine Shop2008 Winners + −
BEST Bakery BEST Coffee Shop BEST Gourmet Grocery BEST Ice Cream Shop BEST Wine Shop
