Voting Home / Great Meals / BEST Traditional American
| Nominee | Address | Rank |
|---|---|---|
| Aunt Judy's Country Kitchen | 377 E Jefferson St Franklin, IN | #7 |
| Binkley's Kitchen and Bar | 5902 N College Ave Indianapolis, IN | #15 |
| BJ's Brewhouse | Multiple Locations | #15 |
| Bonge's Tavern | 9830 W 280 N Anderson, IN | #5 |
| C.R. Heroes Family Pub | 10570 E. 96th Street Fishers, IN | #6 |
| Chappie's | 12703 Meeting House Rd Carmel, IN | #13 |
| Creation Cafe | 337 W 11th St Indianapolis, IN | #18 |
| Dooley O'tooles | 162 E Carmel Dr Carmel, IN | #14 |
| Grays Cafeteria | 555 S Indiana St Mooresville, IN | #11 |
| Hal's Fabulous Vegas Bar & Grille | 1133 N State Road 135 Greenwood, IN | #8 |
| Historic Steer-In | 5130 E 10th St Indianapolis, IN | #19 |
| Hollyhock Hill | 8110 N College Ave Indianapolis, IN | #9 |
| MCL Restaurant & Bakery | Multiple Locations | #1 |
| Papa Roux | 8950 E 10th St Indianapolis, IN | #3 |
| Pipers Cafe and Grand Manor | 2130 W Southport Rd Indianapolis, IN | #17 |
| Sahm's Place | 2411 E 65th St Indianapolis, IN | #20 |
| Sisters' Place | 215 E Terrace Ave Indianapolis, IN | #3 |
| The Legend | 5614 E Washington Street Indianapolis, IN | #10 |
| The Tie Dye Grill | 1311 N. SHADELAND AVE Indianapolis, IN | #2 |
| Wagon Wheel Eatery | 6383 W Broadway Mc Cordsville, IN | #12 |
2011 Winners + −
BEST Chinese BEST French BEST Greek BEST Indian BEST Italian BEST Mexican BEST Middle Eastern BEST New American BEST Romantic Restaurant BEST Seafood BEST Soul Food BEST Steakhouse BEST Sushi BEST Thai BEST Traditional American2009 Winners + −
BEST Chinese BEST French BEST Greek BEST Indian BEST Italian BEST Mexican BEST Middle Eastern BEST New American BEST Romantic Restaurant BEST Seafood BEST Soul Food BEST Steakhouse BEST Sushi BEST Thai BEST Traditional American2008 Winners + −
BEST Chinese BEST French BEST Indian BEST Italian BEST Mediterranean BEST Mexican BEST New American BEST Romantic Restaurant BEST Seafood BEST Steakhouse BEST Sushi BEST Thai BEST Traditional American