Powered by CityVoter
Mama Carolla’s Old Italian
Listed In: Italian
Mama Carolla’s Old Italian
1031 E 54th St
Indianapolis
IN
46220
Tel: (317) 259-9412
Get directions
Come see why many call this the best Italian in Indianapolis!
Login or Sign-Up to review this business
Posted by: lucil , 8/15/2008
Useful?
+0
Great atmosphere!!! Food is superb and servers friendly and efficient
Useful?
+0
If you haven't had the mussels, you haven't lived!!
Useful?
+0
Wonderful food!
Useful?
+0
Best Italian!
Useful?
+0
Roamntic as any good italian plce should be!
Useful?
+0
DELICIOUS! :)
Posted by: jull , 8/9/2008
Useful?
+0
great food, great atmosphere
Useful?
+0
The only one for me is Mama Carolla's!
Useful?
+0
Vote for Mama!
Useful?
+0
Simply the BEST!
Useful?
+0
Everything is great.
Useful?
+0
I love the setting in the old house tucked away next to the trail. The wedding ball soup is out of this world! Service is great too!
Useful?
+0
The rating says it all. Amazing
Useful?
+0
By far, the best Italian in Indianapolis!
Useful?
+0
This should be a dual entry in Most Romantic Restaurant, or Best Atmosphere. Excellent food, and the ambiance is rare for the area!
Useful?
+0
Great food, location, and atmosphere. Superb!
Useful?
+0
Best Bolognese sauce I've ever had. Prices are reasonable and the house Chianti is decent and inexpensive.
Useful?
+0
Great Ambiance! Definitely my FAVORITE date night place with my husband!
Useful?
+0
Every time I have gone it has been crowded, but I have never felt rushed. I wish it were closer, because I would become a regular. Delicious and a wonderful experience!
Useful?
+0
Mama Carolla's is REALLY good! The food is excellent and the atmosphere is perfect, I love it!
Best Italian in Indianapolis
